This is all my opinion.
David played an AMAZING game, managed to make it to the end without getting nominated, and he won a season in which EVERYONE was playing hard. Best winner.
Shane played a dominant game, and managed to get to the end without receiving eviction votes.
Alec and Joe are both meh, but I put Alec above Joe because Alec wasn’t that huge of a target compared to Joe. Not discrediting their games, they did the best they could in their seasons.
Honestly forgot about Seth, but I guess that says a lot. Sorry, Seth.
Geremi is last by default because his game wasn’t real. It was scripted.
Share your winner rankings too!